“Undoubtedly, EVs are most cost efficient for consumers who have the capability to utilize home- and work-based AC charging on a regular basis,” Martin points out. “Charging at home will prove to be difficult and, in some cases impossible, especially for residents of multifamily dwellings who don’t have access to dedicated parking. A reliance on externally sourced charging, such as DC fast charging, can be as pricey as filling a tank of gasoline, eliminating the primary economic benefit of EV ownership.”

• Delays and uncertainties due to funding support, infrastructure and market acceptance, as well as many other factors inherent in introducing new fuels and energy systems.

“The path to the future for ICEs is well underway,” claims Schaeffer. “It involves building on past progress to meet new emissions and fuel efficiency requirements, and a considerable increase in the use of low-carbon fuels like renewable gasoline, renewable diesel, renewable natural gas, biodiesel and hydrogen, as well as e-fuels now under development.”

At last month’s Bauma trade show in Munich, Germany, several exhibitors unveiled next-generation diesel engines for off-highway applications.

Cummins Inc. showcased the X15, the latest addition to its HELM fuel-agnostic engine platform designed to power large construction equipment such as cranes, excavators and wheel loaders. It delivers up to 10 percent better fuel economy vs. previous models, with comparable ratings and duty cycles. The engine is compatible with a variety of current, and future, low- and zero-carbon fuels, including natural gas, clean diesel and hydrogen.

Liebherr Group unveiled a combustion engine powered by ammonia, which is becoming an increasingly popular fuel in the maritime and mining industries. Ammonia has 10 times the energy density of lithium-ion batteries and, unlike hydrogen, does not need to be stored in high-pressure tanks.

Suppliers are also playing an active role in improving combustion engines. One company leading the way is Tenneco Inc., a Tier One firm that specializes in power train and ride performance products. Its brands include Federal-Mogul, Fel-Pro, Monroe and Walker.

“Electrification will not come as fast as we earlier thought,” says Christian Herbst-Dederichs, vice president of power train product and technology at Tenneco. “Therefore, we need to think about alternative strategies.

“The combustion engine has a lot of advantages,” claims Herbst-Dederichs. “There’s also a cost-performance tradeoff that has to be taken into consideration. For instance, the cost of battery-powered vehicles is still higher than gas-powered cars.”

Tenneco engineers have been working on creative ways to take traditional internal combustion engines to the next level, making them cleaner, more efficient and sustainable.

“One way is to increase the thermal efficiency of the combustion,” notes Herbst-Dederichs. “Another way is electrification of auxiliary devices, such as oil and water pumps. Last, but not least, is hybridization.”

According to Herbst-Dederichs, many efforts to improve internal combustion have focused on improving part-load efficiency. “Engine part-load optimization (operating engines at low load cycles) can reduce emissions and cut fuel costs,” he points out. “For instance, we can use valve timing technology to change the compression ratio.

“Friction reduction is also an important way to improve ICE power trains,” says Herbst-Dederichs. “Reducing the viscosity of oil enables it to move easier inside engines. However, with thin oil, mechanical wear reduction is a challenge that needs to be addressed.”

Tenneco’s DuroGlide coated piston rings are designed to reduce friction and increase wear resistance on sliding surfaces, which results in improvements in fuel efficiency and CO2 reduction.

Herbst-Dederichs also says alternative fuels, such as hydrogen, can improve the operating efficiency of combustion engines. That’s why Tenneco has doubled down on efforts to develop hydrogen internal combustion engine (H2-ICE) critical components for the commercial vehicle sector. In fact, it recently opened a hydrogen materials test laboratory in Nuremberg, Germany, in addition to new state-of-the-art test cells at facilities in Burscheid, Germany, and Ann Arbor, MI.

“These additions enhance [our] research and development capabilities aimed at accommodating the soaring demand for hydrogen propulsion for agriculture, construction and heavy-duty trucking,” says Herbst-Dederichs. “By investing in cutting-edge infrastructure and research, we aim to accelerate the adoption of hydrogen power and contribute to global efforts to reduce carbon emissions.”

A New ICE Age?

There are a number of ways that automotive engineers can make ICE power trains cleaner and more efficient. In particular, S&P Global Mobility’s Martin cites several promising innovations, including:

• Pairing with varying levels of electrification. “This can be done in a way that focuses the primary operating range of the ICE in its ‘sweet spot’ for fuel efficiency and power delivery,” says Martin.

• Optimizing the transmission pairing. “Implementation of multispeed and dual-clutch automated transmissions can help maintain ICE operation at lower operating rpm,” explains Martin. “This can help improve fuel economy and reduce emissions.”

• Development of alternative operating cycles. “There have been developments made in the improvement of existing operating cycles, as well as development of new operating cycles,” notes Martin. “Improvements in operating cycles have tended to focus on variable geometry and timing. Variable valve lift, variable valve timing, cylinder deactivation and even variable compression ratio have been implemented, and some can see additional widespread usage. There are also opportunities in advances in exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) that capture, clean and reuse exhaust gases to better enrich the combustion mixture, allowing for cleaner and more efficient burning of fuel.”

• Capture Technologies. “Diesel particulate filters have been in use for quite some time,” says Martin. “Similarly, gas particulate filters are seeing growth as regional regulations focus more on hydrocarbon and nitrous oxide particulate emissions.”

According to some experts, thermal efficiency is key to making ICE power trains cleaner and more efficient. That’s because gas-powered vehicles waste up to 80 percent of the energy in their fuel. Most of the energy ends up as heat, and only a small fraction actually reaches the wheels because of the multistep process that ignites pistons and turns crankshafts. Diesel engines traditionally have better efficiency, but much less than EVs.

Thermal efficiency can be broken down into four areas:

• Thermodynamic efficiency, which relates to all of the heat losses from engines. This can be improved using exhaust gas recirculation or lean-burn operation.

• Gas exchange efficiency relates to pumping losses. This can be improved through the adoption of variable valve trains.

• Mechanical efficiency relates to friction losses, which can be reduced using low-friction coatings.

• Combustion efficiency relates to whether all the fuel takes part in combustion.

“Sustainable fuels, such as biofuels, e-fuels, hydrogen and methanol, will play a big role in helping to reduce CO2 emissions,” predicts Ricardo’s Osborne. “One option for this will include ‘drop-in’ fuels that could be used to supplement traditional diesel or gasoline, either partially or completely.

“This could help to overcome some of the infrastructure challenges relating to universal adoption of electric vehicles,” says Osborne. “And, it will be helpful for off-highway vehicles and maritime applications, and countries where there is a lot of distance between recharging infrastructure.

“The auto industry will also be able to find improvements by looking at the entire vehicle life cycle, such as considering emissions generated during resource extraction or energy used as part of manufacturing,” Osborne points out.

In addition, other technologies are being deployed, such as hybridization, which combines the advantages of ICE and EV technology.

“A key benefit of hybridization is that it enables engines to run over a narrower operating window, allowing them to be optimized specifically for those conditions,” explains Osborne. “An example of this is Ricardo’s Magma xEV research project where we used hybridization to improve brake thermal efficiency by 45 percent.

“We are also finding that single-cylinder research engines still play a vital role in engine development, as they enable OEMs and suppliers to test, refine and enhance performance and efficiency, while reducing emissions in both gas and diesel engines,” says Osborne.

“In addition, artificial intelligence and machine learning technology are being used in engine development,” notes Osborne. “This allows manufacturers to simulate an engine over a lot of different operating cycles and conditions, and identify efficiency improvements without the need to run the vehicle.”

“Combined with a growing momentum toward in-vehicle digitalization and smart monitoring leveraging cutting-edge sensors, real-time diagnostics and AI-driven engine control systems, gas and diesel vehicles continue delivering optimal performance, enhanced efficiency, and extended engine life and performance,” adds Amit Chadha, CEO and managing director of L&T Technology Services Ltd.

“The trend toward more efficient and greener ICE vehicles involves the adoption of innovative combustion techniques like homogeneous charge compression ignition and low-temperature combustion to improve efficiency, while reducing harmful emissions,” says Chadha. “There is also an accelerated shift toward the use of lightweight materials, advanced engineering across high-strength alloys and composites, and precision manufacturing of engine components to minimize weight and energy losses.”

New Engine Reveals Future Power Train Concept

At last month’s Auto Shanghai trade show, Horse Powertrain Ltd. unveiled a compact, modular hybrid engine that provides a glimpse of how some light passenger vehicles could be powered in the near future. The start-up company is a joint-venture between China’s Geely Automobile Holdings and France’s Renault Group.

The Future Hybrid Concept integrates an internal combustion engine (ICE), electric motor and transmission into a single, compact unit. It enables automakers to meet changing customer demand, while eliminating the need for multiple platforms and production lines.

The lightweight power train fits within existing battery electric vehicle (BEV) platforms, and serves as a range extender to the existing battery, with its transmission and driveshafts enabling all-wheel-drive operation both in EV and parallel modes. It can be powered by a range of fuel types, including gasoline, ethanol, flex fuels and pure methanol.

The Future Hybrid Concept consolidates the complex hybrid power train component stack into one compact unit, achieving significant system integration efficiencies. By eliminating most of the tooling and unique manufacturing steps required for pure hybrid engine assembly and installation, the architecture also saves significant resources for OEMs that want to produced mixed propulsion vehicles on the same line.

“For over a decade, it looked like BEVs were the only path to net zero, and OEMs planned accordingly,” says Matias Giannini, CEO of Horse Powertrain. “However, we’re now shifting toward a technology-neutral world, with different markets and applications each pursuing their own sustainable mobility journey.

“Our Future Hybrid Concept helps [automakers] solve this problem,” claims Giannini. “This compact, integrated power train concept allows OEMs to offer power train diversity with minimal disruption to production processes and resource expenditures.”

“The Future Hybrid Concept is designed as a single-piece combustion engine, motor and transmission unit, reducing the complexity of a hybrid power train,” adds Ragnar Burenius, chief engineer of xHEV systems at Horse Powertrain. “This allows more flexibility for its packaging, enabling it to be integrated into existing BEV platforms with minimal vehicle modifications.

“The compact size and geometry of the [system] has been designed to replace the front electric drive unit of a BEV,” explains Burenius. “Requiring only minor modifications, the power train bolts directly to a vehicle’s subframe, allowing OEMs to offer hybrid models on BEV platforms without having to commit to significant redesigns. It can also fit a traditional combustion vehicle platform."

Future Challenges

By harnessing AI, automotive engineers hope to make further improvements to ICE power trains. “However, there are limits on what physics is able to do with combustion engine efficiency,” warns Tom Howell, conventional power train segment leader at AVL List GmbH, a company that specializes in developing and testing sustainable power systems for road, rail and marine vehicles. “It will be hard to get beyond 53 percent thermal efficiency with diesel engines, which has already been achieved by engineers in China.”

“There are still improvements that can be made to make combustion engines cleaner and more efficient,” argues Ricardo’s Osborne. “For passenger vehicles, there remains a focus on tailpipe emissions. Regulations such as the Euro emissions standards have led to real improvements in air quality. When the Euro 7 regulations are implemented [in late 2027], ICE vehicles will approach zero-impact levels of pollutant emissions.

“Life-cycle assessment (LCA) is also a vital tool that can be used to compare the environmental impact of different power train types,” explains Osborne. “When we’ve worked with manufacturers and suppliers in the automotive industry on LCAs, we’ve been able to identify hot-spot areas of environmental impact in the life cycle which can be prioritized for improvements. This includes things such as energy usage, material sourcing and waste reduction.”

“Non-exhaust emissions are an area where there is room for improvement, regardless of vehicle type, such as tire and brake emissions that can be damaging to health,” says Osborne. “With the introduction of Euro 7, we will see the first standards in this area. But, there is more work that manufacturers can do to reduce these types of emissions, which will help reduce environmental impact and improve human health.

“The final issue we need to tackle is how we can produce enough sustainable fuels for all industries, including vehicle use,” notes Osborne. “This is where having a diverse range of fuel types can play a role.”

“One of the biggest challenges going forward will be the ability to manage the cost to implement multiple technologies as the scale of production of most ICE products is gradually reduced,” adds Martin. “In most cases, these technologies are not customer selectable and therefore not considered customer pay options.

“There are also challenges involved in the integration of multiple technologies, in many cases in parallel with some degree of electrification,” warns Martin. “The controls engineering required to execute these broad-based solutions continues to grow in complexity.”